Tags
abuse, desire, forgiveness, hope, redemption, sexuality, spirituality, trust
You’re my daughter. I can do what I want.”
This is the time of year in the Jewish tradition that one focuses with intent on matters of redemption and forgiveness. We look deeply into ourselves through the mirror of the past year, making a frank appraisal of our thoughts and our conduct towards our friends and family, our communities, ourselves. Whenever possible, we are to approach those who we may have harmed, and offer up apology and request for forgiveness from the injured parties. We are to allow ourselves to be open to those who approach us with a willing spirit, asking the same of us. Over the years I have been an exuberant participant in the rituals related to Selichot, the penitential prayer period. It feels right to tell someone I am sorry for any hurt I may have inflicted, intentionally or unintentionally, and to grant forgiveness to those who apologize for their own transgressions. In some instances it has been difficult, but never has there been any regret for apology or forgiveness. It lightens the load of living, it really does.
There is one exceptional challenge in this process for me. Every year I run up against it, and though I see it from a different angle each time, it remains impervious to this redemptive process. I have made my usual attempts to find it in my heart, for myself as much as the other, to forgive egregious transgressions. I have also gone at it from the other side, bringing into the light some of the issues and asking for the opportunity to work together through some aspects of it, but I have met with the strongest denial and resistance. In other words, I have asked to be offered an opportunity to resolve bad feelings and be offered apology for transgression against me, and I have attempted to freely give forgiveness in the absence of such an offering. I pirouette and do running jumps and backward flips and I remain where I stand.
I am a sexual abuse survivor. The perpetrator was my mother. Until very recently, I shared this truth with precious few. I have since shared the truth with a handful of friends. Only recently have I begun to realize that I harm not only myself by keeping my truth the world’s best-kept secret. It denies others the possibility of understanding that yes, there are mothers who sexually abuse their children. It does harm to other women (and men) who feel they are truly the only person on earth who has survived this particular abuse, that there is nowhere to turn, no one who can understand their experience. There is a fair amount in the literature that reflects belief about the destruction wrought due to sexual abuse by one’s own mother. The shattering of innocence by the primary nurturer, the one who we ought to be able to run to when we are hurt, or scared, or in danger, is seen as emotionally devastating for the survivor. But few seem to have actually met any of us. There is a belief that it is rare, that the maternal impulse is that strong. Perhaps it is. But I suspect it is not as rare as we wish to believe.
I have a love for life that is immeasurable. I am still here because of it, and I say with no posturing that there have been times that I have wondered if I should even bother living with the memories, the scars layered on my emotional terrain thick and rough-edged. I’ve come to understand that what happened to me was not my fault, I had no power to control it, and that it doesn’t have to dictate my every move. But there is the layer below the intellectualizing where I live with the visceral knowledge of the devastation left behind. I no longer swim in its waters daily. I have survived and thrived in numerous ways. But the body doesn’t lie. It has taken a systematic approach to reclaiming my body, its feelings and functions, without shame or anger towards it. I have had some success in exploring this new path, and I have become ferocious in defense of my sensuous nature and I am a champion of anyone else walking a path of such self-discovery.
The image that accompanies this piece was not of my own hand. It’s the creation of Eric Abernethy, nature and wildlife photographer. Part of his “mirror” series, I use it with his permission. I see in it a reflection of where I have been when immersed in sensory experience. Many abuse survivors report having a lack of feeling during sex, of an inability to respond. Even when receiving otherwise safe and nurturing touch, sensation is distorted or absent. In my consenting relationships, I’ve never lost the ability to respond, to sense, to feel. What I’ve had was a hatred for my body and its ability to feel. I’ve engaged in some strange mental wanderings to survive it, swimming deep at times. There is some wreckage at the bottom of the lake. There are gems down there, too. I did not know this for a long time. Soon I will tell you more about what I found along the way. It is terrifying to put this out there for others to see, but I intuitively know that it’s the only way for me to move forward.
You have written an amazing beginning, Deb. It is having the very compassionate effect that you had hoped for. Others can learn from this, perhaps have the strength to share……………….and all of us can learn to believe in ourselves. Thank you!
Mary, your words mean a great deal to me. I’m glad it has the impact that I had hoped for–not simply about the fact of abuse and it’s devastation, but so much more about life, and hope, and even redemption. Thank you.
There was a post on an Asperger’s page the other day, to the effect that often the worst bullies are parents. A painful truth- among my comments is that, even if unknowing, complete forgiveness is hard to come by. As you said, the whole violation of trust thing, lack of understanding….
Even worse, as in your case, when it is sexual abuse. Can sympathize with the extreme difficulty of atonement. Congratulations on a brave first step! ❤
Thank you, Roger. You words, your encouragement, mean a lot to me. I know that you have had your personal battles, and I appreciate you sharing that about the Asperger thread, too.
I am, Deborah, coming to this post very, very late, but I just want to tell you how utterly courageous a piece of writing it is. The whole piece is lovely, but I resonated in particular with the word “ferocious” in this: “I have become ferocious in defense of my sensuous nature and I am a champion of anyone else walking a path of such self-discovery.” There is a ferocity in survival, I think, sometimes it’s quiet, sometimes it’s not, but it is ferocity nonetheless. I am happy for you that you have named yours. It will carry you far.
Thank you so much, Richard. You got it exactly right. I want to post “Part Two” but I find I need to turn such things over and over in my mind before I sit and write them down. I’ll tell you one thing now, as to not waste any more time: you telling your story was a huge part of my getting to the point that I could see how telling my own story is not only an act of courage, but an act of thriving. I’ve survived, that’s for sure. Everything I’ve done since the moment I had language for what I have survived is about thriving, and yet I still denied myself the right to tell my story. So thank you for your courage.
Opening your website yesterday and scrolling down for the first time I was stunned by the photo preceding this text. It was searing and painfully sexual. A warning, perhaps. As you know, I didn’t get to read this until you were gone. I had already guessed the context but then was shocked even more by the villain. You have obviously worked very hard to heal yourself and you have written so eloquently about it. I would not have guessed…….my new friend, who feels very much like an old friend, is so full of the enjoyment of life. You are a survivor………and I am so glad that you have entered my life because I am better for it.
Your comments hearten me, Lisa. It was a scary thing, putting this out there for everyone to read, and as you can see from the time that has passed since I posted it, I’ve held off on Part Two. Not for lack of thoughts but wanting to take the next step well.
I, too, feel very fortunate to have found you as a friend at this stage of my life. We shall have many more important conversations. I can feel it.
Pingback: On Forgiveness, Trust, and Desire (Part Two) | Visions of Song
Hi Deborah,
I’m not sure if you’ll come across this comment as I’m finding this post very late. In the event you do, I wanted to thank you for sharing…the phrase you start with (“You’re my daughter, I do what I want”) is the same as what I heard.
It’s true we don’t talk about mother-daughter SA; the result is painfully isolating for survivors. I’m just starting my journey to healing— learning from others’ truths and experiences, knowing I am not alone—gives me hope. Thank you!
Drea,
I am so glad my settings still notify me of comments on postings! I think from time to time about how I shared this (and one other short piece) at a time that I knew it was…well it was time to start voicing my experience. Although I wish you didn’t understand, I am heartened to know that finding this helps you feel a little less alone. It IS painfully isolating. People don’t know what to say, how to act, how to think, even those I’ve known who either experienced some type of sexual abuse or work with survivors. I will be keeping you in my thoughts as you embark on your journey. You know the truth, and you know that people may be uncomfortable with it, but if you’re at the point where you are embarking on a journey, you have likely concluded that you can’t NOT anymore. Peace and hopefulness for you in the days to come!
I appreciate your kind words and well wishes. I wish MDSA wasn’t a thing that united people, something anyone have to grasp- but here we are. Even though truth-telling is hard, I’m glad you have spoken out; for individuals who are in very early stages of healing, it serves as a light.
(Question: would you happen to know if Making Daughters Safe Again is still active?)
Hi, Drea! You know, I am not sure if MDSA is currently active. I believe that Dr. Hatchard, who is the brainchild and the lead therapist for the retreats (or was) is still at Monmouth University, but I haven’t been in touch lately. The year before last I had hoped to attend but was unable to get there, and well…this year they wouldn’t have been able to hold the springtime intensive retreat because of Covid 19. If I learn more, I will update!